The Critic book reviews
4 of the 9 The Critic reviews here with a stated verdict were positive.
MixedThe Castle · Jon Ronson“Does Jon Ronson have anything to tell us about “unravelling” men?”Verdict not statedCommunion · J. D. VanceVerdict not statedA Sudden Flicker of Light · David ThomsonPanGirl on Girl · Sophie Gilbert“Women deserve better histories”Verdict not statedThe New Dark Ages · James MarriottPanWhat If Reform Wins · Peter Chappell“Westminster panic attack in novel form”PositiveFlesh · David Szalay“The story of a lifetime”Verdict not statedOpen Socrates · Agnes CallardPanChanging My Mind · Julian Barnes“being a woke extremist is not confined to Gen Z”PositiveGreat Powers: A History of Britain and Germany · Jan Rüger“these two excellent books”Verdict not statedShattered Lands · Sam Dalrymple“There are many mansions in the house of history but some are built on strange foundations.”Verdict not statedAgainst Identity · Alexander DouglasVerdict not statedAnother World · Melvyn BraggVerdict not statedCrossing the Wine Dark Sea · Emily Wilson“Lost in translation”PanDomination · Alice Roberts“History hamstrung by anti-Christian agenda”Verdict not statedFelled · Andrew HankinsonVerdict not statedFriends in Youth · Minoo DinshawVerdict not statedPassage · Colin ThubronVerdict not statedQueen James · Gareth RussellVerdict not statedThe Grammar of Angels · Edward Wilson-LeePositiveGermany Rearmed · Liana Fix“these two excellent books”PositiveThe Quantity Theory of Morality · Will Self“Self’s the man”