Critics

Evening Standard book reviews

34 of the 48 Evening Standard reviews here with a stated verdict were positive.

PositiveThe Castle · Jon Ronson“Entertainingly leftfield look at the masculinity crisis”PositiveBook of Lives · Margaret Atwood“Fiercely funny tales from a literary mafia don”PanLook What You Made Me Do · John Lanchester“tired Ottolenghi gags masquerading as comedy”PositiveA Hymn to Life · Gisèle Pelicot“A paean to dignity in the face of the unspeakable”PositiveA World Appears · Michael Pollan“got his readers thinking”RaveCool Machine · Colson Whitehead“A triumph of molls, dolls and deadpan humour”Verdict not statedDeparture(s) · Julian BarnesPositiveElectric Spark · Frances Wilson“Muriel is as intriguing as her novels”MixedLife of M · Rachel Cusk“A frustratingly precise character assassination”MixedLong Island · Colm Tóibín“A sequel that doesn't fly quite as high”PositiveThe Eleventh Hour · Salman Rushdie“funny and full of life”PanLand · Maggie O'Farrell“This doomladen tale doesn’t quite land”PositiveNotes to John · Joan Didion“a guilty pleasure”PositiveSwan Song: Diana, My Sister · Charles Spencer“Revenge dish is even better aged 30 years”RaveDead and Alive · Zadie Smith“gives a masterclass in the modern essay”PositiveDrayton and Mackenzie · Alexander Starritt“falls into neither of those traps”RaveDream Count · Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie“a beautifully written triumph”Verdict not statedPerfection · Vincenzo LatronicoPanShadow Ticket · Thomas Pynchon“Thomas Pynchon’s whodunnit is painfully plotless”MixedThe News from Dublin · Colm Tóibín“Colm Tóibín is not a happy bunny in his fiction”PositiveThe Rose Field · Philip PullmanPositiveAfter Oscar · Merlin Holland“It’s impossible not to flinch at the boys’ trauma”PositiveBetween the Waves · Tom McTague“one of the best contemporary writers on the intersection of domestic politics”PositiveMuskism · Quinn Slobodian and Ben Tarnoff“A bleak but necessary story of our times”PositiveParallel Lines · Edward St. Aubyn“elegant skewering of the beautiful and the damned”PanThe Land of Sweet Forever · Harper Lee“a shameful scraping of the barrel by her publishers”PositiveTheft · Abdulrazak Gurnah“tightly-plotted excellence”MixedUnleashed · Boris Johnson“selective and oddly melancholy, but what do you expect?”PositiveVulture · Phoebe Greenwood“The darkly comic despair of the foreign correspondent”MixedA Different Kind of Power · Jacinda Ardern“political memoir is merely a warm embrace”PositiveA Voyage Around the Queen · Craig Brown“fun, gossipy life of the Queen”PositiveGliff · Ali Smith“a poetic, dystopian puzzlebox”Verdict not statedHalf His Age · Jennette McCurdy“lets her freak flag fly with angry autofiction debut”PositiveIs a River Alive? · Robert Macfarlane“A beautiful overture for our dying rivers”RaveNonesuch · Francis Spufford“Touching, funny and profound, Francis Spufford’s Nonesuch is a riot”PositiveThe Haves and Have-Yachts · Evan Osnos“There is something of the Hogarthian morality tale about the stories”PositiveThe Names · Florence Knapp“Rather a lot in this intriguing debut novel”Verdict not statedWhat’s With Baum? · Woody AllenMixedDianaworld · Edward White“Dianaworld review: For Diana fans to enjoy — but not to trust”Verdict not statedFrankly · Nicola Sturgeon“The secret to happiness? It’s not politics”PanHooked · ASAKO. YUZUKI“Sadly it just doesn’t fly”PanSon of Nobody · Yann Martel“more proof that Yann Martel is a literary paper tiger”PositiveWorkhorse · Caroline Palmer“an immersion into Noughties New York and the ludicrous world of magazines in their heyday”PositiveFour Thousand Weeks · Oliver Burkeman“challenging and amusing guide to how to make the best use of the limited time we have”MixedGordon Brown · James Macintyre“All duty, no dazzle”PositiveMoney · David McWilliams“an eye-opening history of what makes the world go round”PositiveOn Friendship · Andrew O'Hagan“A charming ode to the benefits of friends”PositiveGaining Ground · Joan Barfoot“a pleasingly unsettling feminist cult classic”PositiveGwyneth: The Biography · Amy Odell“A searing portrait of privilege skewers Hollywood's former golden girl”PositiveFree · Amanda Knox“life affirming memoir that is full of grace”Verdict not statedThe Immortalists · Aleks KrotoskiPanThe Next Day · Melinda French GatesVerdict not statedWages for Housework · Emily CallaciPositiveMinority Rule: Adventures in the Culture War · Ash Sarkar“A light in the dark for leftists”RaveThe Haunted Wood: a History of Childhood Reading · Sam Leith“fair-minded and terrific”Verdict not statedUngovernable · Simon Hart