Critics

The i Paper book reviews

39 of the 67 The i Paper reviews here with a stated verdict were positive.

PositiveBook of Lives · Margaret Atwood“entertaining memoir wittily recounts her life and (many) loves”PositiveJohn & Paul: A Love Story in Songs · Ian Leslie“this book proves otherwise”PositiveLong Island · Colm Tóibín“more than lives up to its predecessor”MixedThe Eleventh Hour · Salman Rushdie“a reminder of the writer's best and worst tendencies”MixedFly, Wild Swans · Jung Chang“the picture Chang paints of contemporary China is depressing”PanNotes to John · Joan Didion“left me feeling grubby”RaveOur Evenings · Alan Hollinghurst“cements Alan Hollinghurst as one of Britain’s best novelists”Verdict not statedSwan Song: Diana, My Sister · Charles SpencerPanDead and Alive · Zadie Smith“patchy and strangely bloodless”PositiveRevenge of the Tipping Point · Malcolm Gladwell“as eye-opening as The Tipping Point”PositiveSonny Boy: A Memoir · Al Pacino“Godfather fans will love Al Pacino's memoir”MixedThe Rose Field · Philip Pullman“makes me wonder if Pullman should have left this story back when Lyra and Will parted ways in 2000”PanWill There Ever Be Another You · Patricia Lockwood“I never thought I’d find a Patricia Lockwood novel so boring”MixedAll the Way to the River · Elizabeth Gilbert“has one big problem”PositiveMy Good Bright Wolf · Sarah Moss“haunting, revelatory memoir littered with sentences you want to read again and again”PanParallel Lines · Edward St. Aubyn“destined to disappoint his readers”RavePlayground · Richard Powers“it’s a magnificent one”MixedThe Land of Sweet Forever · Harper Lee“charming – but what if she never wanted them published?”PositiveThe Proof of My Innocence · Jonathan Coe“a hugely fun political satire of the Truss days”Verdict not statedTonight the Music Seems So Loud · Sathnam SangheraPanUnleashed · Boris Johnson“Nothing can prepare you for how boring this memoir is”PositiveWe Did OK, Kid: A Memoir · Anthony Hopkins“A thoughtful memoir giving insight into his craft, addiction and recovery”PositiveFreedom · Angela Merkel“candid and sometimes gripping”RaveGabriel's Moon · William Boyd“gripping, must-read spy thriller”MixedGliff · Ali Smith“a clever novel – but not a moving one”MixedHow Not to Be a Political Wife · Sarah Vine“gossipy zeal and an astonishing lack of self-awareness”MixedLazarus Man · Richard Price“binge-worthy but clunky”PositivePatriot · Alexei Navalny“are eerie and extraordinary”PositiveQuestion 7 · Richard Flanagan“a moving blend of memoir, history and philosophy”PositiveShattered · Hanif Kureishi“a remarkable tale of resilience”RaveKarla’s Choice · Nick Harkaway“has resurrected his father’s books brilliantly”PositiveThe City Changes its Face · Eimear McBride“this author shows us how powerful that can be”PositiveThe Fallen · Louise Brangan“A devastating new book reveals a century of shame”PositiveThe Flower Bearers · Rachel Eliza Griffiths“a painful insight into Salman Rushdie’s stabbing”Verdict not statedThe Women’s Orchestra of Auschwitz · Anne SebbaVerdict not statedThis Dark Night · Deborah LutzPositiveAll Fours · Miranda July“this is the one you need to read”PanAll the Wrong Moves · Anthony Scaramucci“he certainly lacks ideas in his new book”MixedConfessions · Catherine Airey“it doesn’t quite live up to hype”MixedPrecipice · Robert Harris“a solid and pleasurable thriller - if it it weren't for one issue”MixedSource Code · Bill Gates“surprising missed opportunity in Bill Gates’s memoir”RaveTell Me Everything · Elizabeth Strout“Strout's latest is a dream read”RaveThe Forbidden Garden of Leningrad · Simon Parkin“is a history book as gripping as a thriller”PositiveLove in Exile · Shon Faye“its greatest strength is its optimism”RavePolitics on the Edge · Rory Stewart“one of the punchiest I've read”PanThe City and Its Uncertain Walls · Haruki Murakami“reads like it’s for children”MixedThe Colour of Home · Sajid Javid“moving but frustrating, with a disconnect between his personal experiences and political credo”PositiveThe Party · Tessa Hadley“captivating – you’ll read it in a day”RaveThe Position of Spoons, and Other Intimacies · Deborah Levy“a scorching, poignant collection of essays”PanWe Who Wrestle With God · Jordan B. Peterson“made me cry – with boredom”PanCitizen: My Life After the White House · President Bill Clinton“nothing but limp, uneventful PR prose”RaveDisappoint Me · Nicola Dinan“her follow up is just as good”MixedDownfall · Nadine Dorries“paranoid fantasies - you have to admire her chutzpah if nothing else”MixedFires Which Burned Brightly · Sebastian Faulks“fascinating, enlightening and erratic”MixedFree · Amanda Knox“Knox's words of empowerment only reveal how lost she is”Verdict not statedGeneration Maybe · Camilla Cavendish“led to a global fertility crisis”PanI Haven't Been Entirely Honest With You · Miranda Hart“the pseudoscience is repellant”PositiveRosarita · Anita Desai“a poignant novella fuelled by family secrets”PositiveSweat · Emma Healey“will get under your skin”RaveThe Blue Hour · Paula Hawkins“even better than The Girl on the Train”RaveThe Correspondent · Virginia Evans“there's one clear winner in my book”RaveThe Ministry of Time · Kaliane Bradley“an exquisite, wildly funny debut”PositiveThe Secret Painter · Joe Tucker“an utterly charming read”PanThe Unfinished Harauld Hughes · Richard Ayoade“it’s utterly tedious”RaveThe Voyage Home · Pat Barker“an electrifying end to the Troy trilogy”MixedWe All Shine On: John, Yoko & Me · Elliot Mintz“a portrait of John Lennon as a self-indulgent manchild”PanDare I Say It · Naomi Watts“if you want a truly great take, read one of the others instead”PositiveKilling Time · Alan Bennett“No one writes about death better than Alan Bennett”PositiveMyself and Other Animals · Gerald Durrell“his writing is charming and hilarious”PositiveOver the Rainbow: Tales from an Unexpected Year · Alex James“a droll collection of first-world problems”PositiveThe Fathers · John Niven“so devastating I had to stop reading”PositiveThe Salt Path · Raynor Winn“It is fascinating to read a book at which so much shade has been thrown”