Critics

New Scientist book reviews

19 of the 26 New Scientist reviews here with a stated verdict were positive.

RaveExit Party · Emily St John Mandel“stunning sci-fi trip to a parallel world”Verdict not statedA World Appears · Michael PollanPositiveVigil · George Saunders“are sci-fi treats”MixedWhen Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows · Steven Pinker“Shame the politics muddies the waters”Verdict not statedThe Score · C. Thi NguyenMixedIs a River Alive? · Robert Macfarlane“is wrong to cast rivers as life forms in new book”PositiveCrick: A Mind in Motion · Matthew Cobb“Francis Crick's biography is full of surprises”PanIf Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies · Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares“superficially appealing but fatally flawed”PositiveVanishing World · Sayaka Murata“intriguing new novel from Sayaka Murata”RaveWe Are Not Machines · Sarah O'Connor“an excellent look at the future of work”PositiveAfter the Spike · Dean Spears and Michael Geruso“Provocative new book says we must persuade people to have more babies”PositiveOff the Scales · Aimee Donnellan“a powerful book reframes how we see obesity”PositiveProto · Laura Spinney“An elegant account of how one ancient language went global”Verdict not statedDomination · Alice RobertsMixedHawking · Graham Farmelo“should be applauded for digging into various controversies – but could have gone further”PositiveLife Out of Order · Audrey Niffenegger“an intricate and thoughtful vision of a frightening future”Verdict not statedLove Machines · James Muldoon“looks into the relationships we're forging with them”PositiveOn the Equality of All Things · Carlo Rovelli“a compelling new book”PositiveThe Ego Trip · Kimon de Greef“The wild, gripping story of the psychedelic secreted by desert toads”Verdict not statedThe Midnight Train · Matt Haig“teeters on the edge of science fiction”PositiveUnder a Metal Sky · Philip Marsden“an engrossing look at how we have excavated key metals and rocks”Verdict not statedAlive · Melanie Challenger“Melanie Challenger's Alive aims to describe the living world very differently”MixedCircular Motion · Alex Foster“We liked it – but there were calls for a bit more science”PositiveClearing the Air · Hannah Ritchie“is a breath of fresh air”RaveJuice · Tim Winton“terrifying and brilliant”PositiveThe Elements of Marie Curie · Dava Sobel“shows Dava Sobel's detailed and intimate new biography”RaveThe Immortalists · Aleks Krotoski“brilliantly dispassionate reporting”MixedThe Origin of Language · Madeleine Beekman“Michael Marshall is intrigued, but wants more evidence”RaveTogetherness · Rowan Hooper“makes thrilling reading”PositiveUnder Story · Chloe Benjamin“Ambitious sci-fi novel imagines a universe where time flows backwards”MixedA Climate of Truth · Mike Berners-Lee“may be just too hard”PositiveLuminous · Silvia Park“a fascinating take on robots”